Dreading Your Next Mistake Doesn’t Mean You’re Failing

A first-year resident wrote on Reddit this month that attendings keep telling them they are doing well, and it changes nothing. Every shift they wait for the bigger mistake they are sure is coming. They won’t mention the fear at work in case it gets them labeled, and they have started wondering whether a lower-acuity specialty would be safer. This part of our guide to surviving residency makes one argument: that dread tells you where you are in training, not whether you belong in medicine, and keeping it secret is the surest way to make it last.

How many residents carry the same fear

You are in large company. An AMA report on impostor feelings in residency cites research putting rates among residents between 33% and 44%. A 2025 single-center study of 56 anesthesiology and emergency medicine residents in the Brazilian Journal of Anesthesiology found 45% met its threshold for impostor phenomenon, and higher scores tracked with emotional exhaustion and depersonalization. The samples are small, but the point holds: many people on your team are running the same private calculation, including the ones who look calm on rounds.

Vigilance and dread feel alike but do different jobs

Some fear earns its keep. The intern who rechecks a potassium before giving more, or pages about a soft blood pressure instead of waiting, is acting on caution aimed at a specific risk. That kind of worry ends in an action: a recheck, a page, a question.

The corrosive version has no object. It is about a mistake that hasn’t happened, on a patient you haven’t met, and nothing you do on shift settles it. Try this at the end of a day: write down what you were afraid of. If each item names a patient and a decision (“I wasn’t sure the heparin dose was right for her weight”), that is vigilance, and it has an answer you can go get. If the list reads “I’ll miss something eventually,” that is dread. No amount of rechecking will close it, because it was never about a particular chart.

Why hiding the fear keeps it going

Confidence in training rarely shows up as a feeling first. It builds from feedback: someone more senior looks at what you did and tells you whether it was right. Hide your uncertainty and you cut off that supply. One new resident spent days after a first emergency department shift wondering whether a workup and handoff had missed something, and named the real problem: no senior had reviewed the case, so there was nothing to check the worry against. The fear moved into the space where feedback should have been.

Researchers at Johns Hopkins Bayview interviewed 28 internal medicine residents about what eased their impostor feelings and published the results in the Journal of Graduate Medical Education in 2024. The residents credited accepting feedback, rethinking how they explained their own successes, mentors, and settings where admitting uncertainty was normal. The authors urged programs to break skills into smaller pieces, set clear expectations and build psychological safety. You can do the first two yourself this week.

Turn second-guessing into questions a senior can answer

“Am I doing okay?” is too vague to help. The fix is to ask about a decision instead of about yourself.

After a case you keep replaying: “Can you look at how I handled bed 12 overnight? I want to know if you’d have done anything differently.” You get a verdict on a real choice instead of reassurance.

Before a step you’re unsure of: “I’m planning to hold the diuretic because her creatinine bumped. Is there something I’m not weighing?” Stating your reasoning first shows judgment, which is what evaluators are watching for, and gives your senior something to correct.

With your advisor or program director: “What would worry you about a resident at my stage? Am I showing any of it?” The answer replaces the imagined standard you’ve been failing with a real one.

Asked this way, you aren’t confessing anxiety. You’re asking for feedback in a form specific enough to change what you believe about your own skills. The surgical intern who posted this month after a procedural error the attending caught and corrected is in a better spot than it feels. An error caught under supervision is training working as designed, and the next case is where that correction pays off.

Hold off on choosing a specialty to escape the fear

The resident eyeing a lower-acuity field is weighing a career decision against how the middle of intern year feels. Lower acuity doesn’t remove the chance of error. Outpatient medicine has its own missed diagnoses and results that come back after the patient has gone home. If another field fits the working life you want, that is a real reason to switch. If the main draw is fewer chances to be wrong, give yourself a year of honest feedback before you decide.

The same logic applies when you weigh first jobs. Ask how new attendings are backed up, who reviews their early cases, and whether there is a partner you can call at 2 a.m. without it counting against you.

If the dread spills past work into sleep, appetite or your days off, take it to a professional. Many residents hold back over licensing worries, so we looked at whether seeing a therapist shows up on your license.

Pick the one case from this week you keep replaying and ask a senior to review it before your next shift. One honest answer about a real decision will do more for your confidence than another month of being told you’re doing fine.

Most interns carry this fear without telling anyone, because the people they’d tell are the ones grading them. DocCommons will pair residents with practicing and retired physicians who remember that same dread from their own first year and can say what actually eased it. The platform is still in development, and you can join the waitlist at doccommons.com.

Relevant articles

Subscribe to our newsletter

Physician workforce news and career advice from PhysEmp, free every week.

The best candidates for your jobs, right in your inbox.

We’ll get back to you shortly

By submitting your information you agree to PhysEmp’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use…